[ Skip to content]

You are here: SCCS >> Home >> Features

Health fears over CO2 storage are unfounded, study shows

12-September-2011, Edinburgh

Capturing CO2 from power stations and storing it deep underground carries no significant threat to human health, despite recently voiced fears that it might, a study has shown.

Researchers found that the risk of death from poisoning as a result of exposure to CO2 leaks from underground rocks is about one in 100 million – far less than the chances of winning the lottery jackpot.

Scientists from the University of Edinburgh studied historical data on deaths from CO2 poisoning in Italy and Sicily, where the gas seeps naturally from the ground because of volcanic activity.

They found that the number of recorded deaths was very low and say that engineered gas storage underground could be even safer, as it will be planned and monitored.

Recent CCS projects in northern Europe and Canada have been criticised by residents over health concerns arising from potential leakage.

Carbon capture and storage enables collection of CO2 before it can escape into the atmosphere. The technology involves the collection of CO2 at a power station or industrial site. The gas is liquefied and piped to the storage site, where it is injected deep below ground. The gas is stored in microscopic rock pores and eventually dissolves in underground water. Storage sites will have several barriers between the store and the surface.

Storing CO2 gas underground prevents it from contributing to global warming. Such technologies will play an important role over the next 50 years, as a bridge to the development of clean energy.

Jennifer Roberts from the University of Edinburgh’s School of GeoSciences, who undertook the work, said: “These Italian CO2 seeps are natural, are often neither sign-posted nor fenced off, and yet there have been remarkably few accidents.”

Professor Stuart Haszeldine of the University of Edinburgh's School of GeoSciences, who led the study, said: "Our findings show that storing CO2 underground is safe and should allay any concerns that the technology poses a significant threat to health."

Full Article:

The study is published in the Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences. The article and the supporting information are open access:

For further information, please contact:
Jennifer Roberts, School Of Geosciences, tel 01316 505936; email Jen.Roberts@ed.ac.uk
Professor Stuart Haszeldine, School of GeoSciences, tel 0131 650 8549; email s.haszeldine@ed.ac.uk
Catriona Kelly, Press and PR Office, Tel 0131 650 4401; email Catriona.Kelly@ed.ac.uk

CO2 Seeps in Italy - Images

Dry CO2 Seep - Rome
Ciampino CO2 dry gas seep, located in a populated area in Rome. Photo taken from domestic flight landing into Rome Ciampino airport. Red elipse outlines the extent of degassing.
Mefite D'Ansanto
The dry gas seep 'Mefite D'Ansanto' is Italy's largest flux CO2 seep. Also a site of archeological interest, the seep has claimed at least 3 human lives in the past twenty years and animal fatalities are not uncommon.
The seep has a warning sign but free public access and is located close to a farm house. Degassing takes place over only a few square meters but is estimated to be over 0.73 Mt of CO2 per year, equivalent to the CO2 output from a small gas fired power station.
Mefitiniella Polla
Mefitiniella Polla, this CO2 vent is located in a field 1km from Mefite D'Ansanto. The seep has claimed animal lives but no human fatalities have occurred. In the background stands University of Edinburgh geologist Jen Roberts.
Distribution of CO2 seeps in Italy.
There are 286 CO2 seeps documented by the INGV (www.ingv.it). These have various CO2 degassing rates and various surface expressions, as indicated by the coloured icons (Base map - Google)
River
A river of CO2-rich waters.
     
   
People | Facilities | Projects | Reports | Publications | Contact
© Scottish Carbon Capture & Storage 2013 | Media Contact | About this Site